![]() |
| From right, Kevin Callinan (IMPACT), Niamh Garvey (Trocáire), Joseph Curtin (IIEA and the Irish Climate Change Advisory Council), Joe O'Connor (IMPACT) who commissioned the report from Joseph Curtin. |
Below is a speech I wrote for the launch of a report on 'Just Transition' commissioned by IMPACT trade union and written by Joseph Curtin of the Institute of International and European Affairs (IIEA).
The report is now available online here and is a brilliant resource for anyone working in the area of climate change or climate justice. Interviews with other speakers are also available at this link. :
I would like to thank Joe O’Connor and Kevin Callinan for their brilliant work in commissioning this project and driving an inclusive participative process with IMPACT members on climate change and what it means for them. Joseph Curtin has done a brilliant job of taking on the role and completing a comprehensive report on the need for a just transition and an analysis of the impacts on IMPACT’s members. I was very sorry when I had to leave the project due to taking a role with the Green Party as a researcher. However, Joseph has done an incredible job with his experience as an economist and policy advisor, creating a ground-breaking document that will lead the way on climate action.
The report is now available online here and is a brilliant resource for anyone working in the area of climate change or climate justice. Interviews with other speakers are also available at this link. :
I would like to thank Joe O’Connor and Kevin Callinan for their brilliant work in commissioning this project and driving an inclusive participative process with IMPACT members on climate change and what it means for them. Joseph Curtin has done a brilliant job of taking on the role and completing a comprehensive report on the need for a just transition and an analysis of the impacts on IMPACT’s members. I was very sorry when I had to leave the project due to taking a role with the Green Party as a researcher. However, Joseph has done an incredible job with his experience as an economist and policy advisor, creating a ground-breaking document that will lead the way on climate action.
The term “Just Transition” in the Preamble of the 2015 Paris
Agreement on Climate Change recognizes this story of how both nature and
workers were made invisible in the Industrial Revolution narrative. Long fought
for by a coalition of environmental NGOs and trade union groups, the 197
country signatories to the UN Framework Agreement on Climate Change must now
take into account the effect of climate action, or inaction, on workers and
their communities.
The core principle of Just Transition, is simple, those who
have the most to lose from climate action, or inaction, need to be included in
the decisions made about them. Climate change must not recreate the wilful
injustice of past economic restructurings such as those inflicted on mining
communities under Thatcher, or the rust-belts of the US caused by neo-liberal
trade agreements such as NAFTA. For too long discussions of climate change have
left out the trade union and worker perspective.
‘Just Transition’ recognizes this fact, that workers are at
the interface between society and nature. From miner’s lung, to Rana Plaza, to
farmers drowning in slurry pits, workers bear the brunt of harm from an
exploitative economic system. Climate-caused drought destroys countries, causes
subsistence poverty and forces refugees to die on Frontex's increasingly
militarised borders. Climate change is at the heart of class conflict and these
are political choices.
Hurricane Katrina and the resulting disproportionate death
rate of African-Americans and the elderly in New Orleans, is a telling example
of how marginalized groups will bear the brunt of the effects of climate
change.
Section 3 of the Climate Action and Low Carbon Development
Act 2015 mandates that the National Mitigation Plan and National Adaptation
Framework are created with regard to climate justice, which incorporates the
principle of just transition. Yet, the most recent draft National Mitigation
Plan by Government completely ignored this requirement.
This lack of understanding of climate justice has resulted
in a situation where the recent announcement of 125 Bord Na Móna job losses
in Littleton came as a complete surprise to workers, many of whom are third or
fourth generation employees in the company, and to the community. After generations
of backbreaking work these communities are being tossed aside. It is a perfect
example of how not to manage economic transition.
These job losses are reflective of the wider situation for
oil and gas employment in Ireland. In October 2016, 170 jobs were lost at a
Cameron plant in Co. Longford due to a downturn in the oil and gas industry.
Investment in the industry is falling rapidly due to reputational damage, the
global divestment movement and the current cheap price of oil. Across the
globe, the fossil fuel industry is suffering heavy losses and becoming more
and more reliant on government subsidies. In 2015/16 around 120,000 jobs were
lost in the UK oil and gas sector alone, with an estimated 441,371 jobs lost
globally as of February 2017. In short, the industry is living on borrowed
time.
Without a comprehensive ‘Just Transition’ plan, the switch
to a low-carbon economy risks a repeat of the inequities of past economic
restructurings - undermining union power and cutting the very heart and pride
out of communities.
Now, in the second Industrial Revolution – the Industrial
Devolution – trade unions again must collective, organise and prepare their members. The new economy will not look like the old one. It will not be
Keynesian and cannot be neoliberal. The shift to a low carbon economy also
offers significant social benefits as well as providing for long-term economic
prosperity. Expanding caring professions which IMPACT represents, such as
nursing, community-work, education, arts, culture, and care-work is an
overlooked but essential part of the shift to a low-carbon world.
The Irish Government must recognise, as all mainstream
economists now do, that there is no such thing as a free market. Governments
influence and co-create a culture of change, they are not innocent bystanders
in the negotiation of economic progress. Public investment in the transition
must be robust and fair, with economic indicators that represent our lives as
reliant on a complex nature of social and environmental ecosystems.
Ireland is not rich in the resources of the fossil fuel era, but it is rich in those of a 21st century economy. With proper planning and investment, we can ensure that the transition to a low carbon economy leaves no worker behind, and ensure a better, fairer economy that distributes wealth to all on a fair and just basis. One has to remember that what economists view as “costs” in analyzing carbon abatement are for the most part investments in new capital stock. The building of that capital stock – such as the internet or university education - creates prosperity.
Ireland is not rich in the resources of the fossil fuel era, but it is rich in those of a 21st century economy. With proper planning and investment, we can ensure that the transition to a low carbon economy leaves no worker behind, and ensure a better, fairer economy that distributes wealth to all on a fair and just basis. One has to remember that what economists view as “costs” in analyzing carbon abatement are for the most part investments in new capital stock. The building of that capital stock – such as the internet or university education - creates prosperity.
All the benefits of the Industrial Revolution and
modernisation – from higher quality of life to advances in medicine - were distributed
amongst ordinary people due to the hard work by trade unions to include, organise
and collectivise the people. As James Connolly said, we only want the earth - and
the wealth of that earth must be shared fairly and sustainably with all. We are
not defending Nature, we are Nature defending itself
We must reject alienation from each other, and from other
forms of life. Reject the false separation of ourselves from our living world and
each other - and fight to create an economy that reflects the mutually
beneficial interdependence of our life on earth: ‘ar scáth a chéile a mhaireann
na daoine’. As SIPTU organiser Adrian Kane says, solidarity does not fall from
the sky, it must be worked for. The suffering of one affects and lessens the
humanity of us all. Our solution to the crisis must be, as eco-feminist Donna
Haraway says, to “Make Kin”.
I’m delighted to have been involved in this project and I
wish Kevin Callinan, Joe O’Connor, Joseph Curtin and IMPACT members the very
best in going forward with such an inclusive, ground-breaking report.
